Milk Snob

Deal

Milk Snob

Season 8 • Episode 8
Melanie Disbrow pitches Milk Snob, a versatile car seat cover that doubles as a nursing cover, seeking $125,000 for 5% equity and ultimately accepts an offer of $150,000 for 10% from Lori Greiner.

Ask Amount

$125,000

Ask Equity

5 %

Deal Amount

$150,000

Deal Equity

10 %

Key Lessons for Founders

Highlight Sales Success
Prepare clear sales metrics to present during pitches.
  • Why: Demonstrating strong sales can significantly enhance investor interest.
Be Open to Negotiation
Set a minimum acceptable equity but be willing to negotiate.
  • Why: Flexibility in equity discussions can lead to better partnership opportunities.
Improve Communication Skills
Engage in public speaking training or practice to build confidence.
  • Why: Effective communication is key to successful pitches and negotiations.

What Worked

Strong Sales Performance
The pitch highlighted impressive sales figures.
  • Evidence: Melanie stated they made $1.2 million in sales over 18 months.
  • Why it matters: Strong sales demonstrate market demand and validate the business model.
  • Coach tip: Always present clear and compelling sales data to attract investor interest.
Product Versatility
The product serves multiple functions, appealing to new parents.
  • Evidence: Melanie explained that the cover can be used as both a car seat cover and a nursing cover.
  • Why it matters: Versatile products often attract a wider audience and increase sales potential.
  • Coach tip: Emphasize unique product features that solve multiple problems.
Engaging Presentation
Melanie's enthusiasm and personal story resonated with the Sharks.
  • Evidence: She shared her journey and the challenges of being a new mom.
  • Why it matters: A relatable story can create a connection with investors and enhance their interest.
  • Coach tip: Incorporate personal anecdotes to make your pitch more relatable.

What Could Be Improved

Equity Negotiation
Melanie was hesitant to give up more than 5% equity.
  • Evidence: She stated she worked hard for the company and didn't want to give up more than 5%.
  • Why it matters: Being inflexible on equity can limit deal options and investor interest.
  • Coach tip: Be prepared to negotiate equity to secure a partnership.
Public Speaking Skills
Melanie admitted to being a poor public speaker.
  • Evidence: She mentioned, 'I'm a horrible public speaker.'
  • Why it matters: Strong communication skills are crucial in pitching to investors.
  • Coach tip: Practice public speaking to build confidence and improve delivery.
Clarification of Offer Terms
The negotiation process became somewhat convoluted.
  • Evidence: There were multiple offers and counteroffers that confused the discussion.
  • Why it matters: Clear communication during negotiations is essential to avoid misunderstandings.
  • Coach tip: Keep negotiations straightforward to maintain clarity and focus.

Shark Pitches helps founders understand how investors actually think, using real Shark Tank pitches as case studies.

Get Weekly Pitch Deep Dives

In-depth, practical deep dives of real Shark Tank pitches.

See how investors think and what actually moves the needle.

One sharp deep dive per week. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.