SiliDog

Deal

SiliDog

Season 8 • Episode 5
Mikey Lickstein pitched SiliDog, a company offering customizable, silent pet tags made from silicone, seeking $100,000 for 15% equity and ultimately secured a deal with Lori Greiner for $100,000 at 30% equity plus $0.50 per tag sold.

Ask Amount

$100,000

Ask Equity

15 %

Deal Amount

$100,000

Deal Equity

30 %

Special Terms

$0.50 per tag sold

Key Lessons for Founders

Be prepared for negotiation.
Have a clear understanding of your minimum acceptable terms.
  • Why: Investors will often counter your initial offer.
Highlight unique selling points.
Clearly articulate what makes your product stand out from competitors.
  • Why: Differentiation is key in attracting investor interest.
Understand your manufacturing capabilities.
Develop a plan for scaling manufacturing as demand increases.
  • Why: Investors need to know you can scale production.

What Worked

Strong sales traction
The company demonstrated impressive sales figures.
  • Evidence: In 14 and a half months, they've done $142,000 in sales.
  • Why it matters: This shows market validation and demand for the product.
  • Coach tip: Highlighting sales achievements can attract investor interest.
Unique product offering
SiliDog's tags solve a common problem for pet owners.
  • Evidence: The tags are silent, never fade, and glow in the dark.
  • Why it matters: This differentiates SiliDog from traditional metal and plastic tags.
  • Coach tip: Emphasize unique features that address customer pain points.
Effective marketing strategy
The company has a clear plan for retail distribution.
  • Evidence: They got into over 90 stores after attending a trade show.
  • Why it matters: This indicates a scalable business model and growth potential.
  • Coach tip: Showcase partnerships and distribution channels to build credibility.

What Could Be Improved

High equity ask
The initial equity offer was perceived as too high.
  • Evidence: Sharks expressed concern over the 15% equity for $100,000.
  • Why it matters: High equity demands can deter investors who seek better value.
  • Coach tip: Consider adjusting equity offers based on feedback from investors.
Customization limitations
The business model relies heavily on customization.
  • Evidence: Investors noted that customized products can limit scalability.
  • Why it matters: Customization can complicate production and inventory management.
  • Coach tip: Explore ways to streamline customization processes to enhance scalability.
Manufacturing concerns
The product is currently made in a garage.
  • Evidence: Mikey mentioned they manufacture the tags in his garage.
  • Why it matters: This raises questions about capacity and quality control as demand grows.
  • Coach tip: Plan for future manufacturing scalability to meet increasing demand.

Shark Pitches helps founders understand how investors actually think, using real Shark Tank pitches as case studies.

Get Weekly Pitch Deep Dives

In-depth, practical deep dives of real Shark Tank pitches.

See how investors think and what actually moves the needle.

One sharp deep dive per week. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.